Why Is EMDR So Controversial?
Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing, or EMDR, is a type of therapy that has gained a lot of attention over the years. It’s often used to help people who have experienced trauma, like veterans, abuse survivors, or those who’ve been through accidents.
But despite its popularity, EMDR is also one of the most debated therapies out there. Some people swear by it, while others are skeptical.
So, why is EMDR so controversial? Let’s break it down.
What Is EMDR, Anyway?
Before we dive into the controversy, let’s talk about what EMDR is. EMDR is a therapy technique created in the late 1980s by psychologist Francine Shapiro.
The idea is that traumatic memories can get "stuck" in the brain, causing emotional pain and distress. EMDR aims to help the brain process these memories so they’re less painful.
During an EMDR session, the therapist guides the patient to recall a traumatic memory while they move their eyes back and forth, usually following the therapist’s finger or a light.
Sometimes, instead of eye movements, the therapist might use taps or sounds. The goal is to help the brain "reprocess" the memory, making it feel less intense.
The Big Question: Does It Work?
One of the biggest reasons EMDR is controversial is that people aren’t sure if it works. Some studies show that EMDR can be effective for treating PTSD (post-traumatic stress disorder) and other trauma-related issues.
Many patients report feeling better after just a few sessions, which is pretty impressive. But here’s the catch: some experts argue that the benefits of EMDR might not come from the eye movements themselves.
Instead, they think it’s the other parts of therapy—like talking about the trauma or learning coping skills—that help people feel better. In other words, the eye movements might just be a fancy add-on that doesn’t do much.
This debate has led to a lot of back-and-forth in the mental health community. Some therapists love EMDR and use it all the time, while others think it’s overhyped.
The Eye Movement Debate
Let’s dig deeper into the eye movement part of EMDR because this is where a lot of the controversy comes from.
The theory behind EMDR is that the eye movements help the brain process traumatic memories, kind of like how your brain processes things during REM sleep (the stage of sleep where you dream).
But not everyone buys this idea. Some researchers say there’s no solid evidence that the eye movements actually do anything special. They argue that the benefits of EMDR could just be from focusing on the traumatic memory in a safe, controlled way—something that happens in other types of therapy too.
On the other hand, supporters of EMDR say the eye movements are a key part of what makes it work.
They point to studies showing that EMDR can be more effective than other therapies for some people. So, the debate continues.
Is EMDR Just a Fad?
Another reason EMDR is controversial is that some people think it’s just a passing trend. Therapy techniques come and go, and not all of them stand the test of time.
Critics worry that EMDR might be one of those flashy, new-sounding therapies that gets a lot of attention but doesn’t have enough science to back it up.
That said, EMDR has been around for over 30 years, which is longer than most therapy fads. It’s also recognized by organizations like the World Health Organization (WHO) and the American Psychological Association (APA) as a valid treatment for PTSD. So, while some people might see it as a fad, it’s clearly got some staying power.
The Role of the Therapist
One thing that’s often overlooked in the EMDR debate is the role of the therapist. Like any type of therapy, the success of EMDR depends a lot on the skill and experience of the therapist.
A good therapist can make a huge difference, whether they’re using EMDR or another approach.
But because EMDR involves specific techniques—like guiding eye movements—some people worry that therapists might rely too much on the method and not enough on building a strong, trusting relationship with their client.
Therapy isn’t just about techniques; it’s about connection and understanding. If a therapist focuses too much on the "gimmick" of eye movements, they might miss the bigger picture.
The Cost of EMDR
Let’s talk about money. EMDR can be expensive, especially if you need multiple sessions.
Some people worry that the high cost of EMDR isn’t justified, especially if the benefits are similar to other, cheaper therapies.
On the flip side, supporters argue that EMDR can work faster than other therapies, which might save money in the long run. For example, someone with PTSD might need months or even years of traditional talk therapy, but only a few sessions of EMDR to feel better.
So, while it might seem pricey upfront, it could be worth it for some people.
The Placebo Effect
Another factor in the EMDR controversy is the placebo effect. This is when someone feels better because they believe a treatment works, not because the treatment itself is doing anything. Some critics say that EMDR’s benefits might be partly due to the placebo effect.
For example, if someone goes into EMDR expecting it to help, they might feel better just because they’re hopeful. This doesn’t mean EMDR is useless—feeling better is still a good thing! But it does raise questions about how much of the therapy’s success is due to the technique itself versus the person’s expectations.
EMDR and Science
Science is all about evidence, and this is where EMDR gets tricky. While some studies show that EMDR works, others are less convincing. The quality of the research varies, and some studies have small sample sizes or other flaws that make it hard to draw firm conclusions.
This doesn’t mean EMDR is fake or doesn’t work—it just means we need more research to understand how and why it works. Until then, the controversy will likely continue.
Should You Try EMDR?
So, should you give EMDR a shot? The answer depends on your situation.
If you’re struggling with trauma and other therapies haven’t helped, EMDR might be worth trying. Many people find it helpful, and it’s generally considered safe. But it’s also important to keep an open mind.
EMDR isn’t a magic cure, and it might not work for everyone. If you decide to try it, make sure you work with a qualified therapist who has experience with EMDR and who you feel comfortable with.
Your healing doesn’t have to look like anyone else’s.
Here, we honor every part of you—your story, your struggles, and your strength. Whether you're exploring past wounds or learning to trust yourself again, this is a space for deep, compassionate healing.
Final Thoughts
EMDR is a fascinating therapy that has helped a lot of people, but it’s not without its critics. The controversy around EMDR comes down to questions about how it works, whether it’s better than other therapies, and if it’s worth the cost.
While the debate isn’t likely to end anytime soon, one thing is clear: EMDR has made a big impact on the world of mental health.
If you’re curious about EMDR, the best thing to do is talk to a therapist or do some research.
Everyone’s experience is different, and what works for one person might not work for another. At the end of the day, the most important thing is finding a therapy that helps you heal and move forward.
Whenever you're ready, I’m here.
Other Services I Can Help You With:
